Reclaiming wages a tough road for temp workers

Eidy Gaspar
Eidy Gaspar is one of several temporary workers who filed a class action lawsuit against Staffing Network, a temporary staffing agency, for allegedly violating multiple state employment laws designed to protect temporary workers. [Photo by Michelle Kanaar]




Eidy Gaspar was surprised when her manager said she wouldn’t be paid overtime anymore. Gaspar, a warehouse worker in suburban Chicago, didn’t object because she feared being blacklisted by the temporary agency that hired her: Staffing Network, one of the largest hiring agencies in Illinois.

The mother of three worked full-time in the warehouse for six years packing books to be shipped to retailers like Target and Walmart. But when she wasn’t paid for her regular 40-hour work week, she confronted her manager. He shifted the burden of proof to her, according to a class action lawsuit she filed in August 2013 against the warehouse and Staffing Network.

“It was absurd. How can they ask me to show proof that I worked those hours?” Gaspar, 37, said in Spanish. “I punched in and out when they told me. They kept the records for those hours."

The class action lawsuit is among three filed in the past three years in the 7th U.S. District Court accusing Staffing Network of violating wage laws. The company has also been sued in county court. In 2006, the hiring firm settled a lawsuit in Cook County Circuit Court alleging that it didn’t pay workers overtime, charged them illegally for transportation costs and failed to keep payroll records. Three years later, the company agreed to pay $400,000 to 10 workers, more than $133,333 in attorney’s fees and an additional $22,300 for other temporary employees, according to the settlement.

Staffing Network says it’s being singled out by labor advocates.

“Despite our compliance with wage hour laws and regulations,” said Cecilia Zuniga, human resource manager for the staffing agency. “We believe that select plaintiffs’ attorneys have unfairly targeted Staffing Network in order to pursue their own agendas, and because we are one of the largest independent staffing firms in Illinois.”

The temp agency is part of a fast-growing sector of the staffing industry that dominates the low-wage labor market, exploiting the most vulnerable and hard-to-employ workers, say labor advocates. As employers increasingly turn to the agencies for hiring flexibility, lower benefit costs and a steady supply of cheap labor, experts say that more low and unskilled workers will have fewer opportunities to pull themselves out of poverty.

Many of the workers are African Americans and Latinos, and several are undocumented and ex-felons.

Undocumented workers are told they don't have rights, while workers with a felony record are told no one else will hire them, said Tim Bell of the Chicago Workers Collaborative, which helped Gaspar file the lawsuit against Staffing Network.

The unspoken rule is that if employees complain, they won’t be hired, he said.

The growth of the temporary staffing industry
In recent years, the staffing industry has evolved from a boutique service to a sector of its own, according to a 2012 University of Illinois at Chicago study entitled “Selling flexibility: temporary staffing in a volatile economy.” That shift is clear in Illinois where the number of temporary workers increased by 30 percent between 2001 and 2011 to 179,890, according to the U.S. Census.

Nearly four out of five employers use some form of temporary staffing arrangement nationally. That number is expected to grow, according to a report by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Changes in the economy and the workforce are driving the growth. Employers like the flexibility staffing agencies offer, the wages are lower and they don’t incur benefit costs. The industry’s growth has also been bolstered by the rising number of unskilled workers who are forced to work for less.

“Contracting out jobs is a mechanism used to reduce compensation,” said Susan Houseman, a labor economist at the W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research who specializes in temporary employment and outsourcing. “That’s a big selling point for temp agencies to employers. You can only hire them when you need them. That can be good for employers to adjust their workflow, but from the workers’ perspective there’s a greater risk.”

When Houseman compared a sample of welfare-to-work participants in Michigan, she found that direct hires significantly improved their wages and were likelier to escape poverty. On the other hand, temp workers were stuck in a revolving door between work and welfare.

There are many types of temporary staffing agencies, she said, but those agencies that provide low-skilled workers tend to rely on workers with felony convictions and undocumented immigrants.

Regulating staffing firms
Despite state and national laws that protect workers, several hiring companies including Prime Staffing, Staffing Solutions Southeast and Paramount Staffing have been sued for allegedly violating minimum wage and overtime compensation laws. Other staffing agencies hire contractors who charge workers between $6 and $8 a day for transportation services and debit card and other fees, according to the lawsuits.

In 2003, City Clerk Susana Mendoza, then a state representative, introduced a bill to regulate the staffing industry. Three years later, Illinois legislators passed the Day and Temporary Labor Service Act, which requires the agencies to document payroll logs for their employees, pay workers at least four hours for each assignment and stop charging them for rides to work and other so-called services.

Illinois is one of a few states with strong protections for temporary workers. But the law means little if workers don’t invoke it.

“Many [co-workers] complained about unpaid missing hours but they never report it because they are afraid,” said Gaspar. “If you complain, the agency will stop giving you work.”

Gaspar said most of her coworkers were Latinos who didn’t speak English or know about U.S. labor laws. Instead of trying to retrieve their wages, they looked for other jobs, she said.

The challenges in filing wage claims
Advocates say even when workers report wage abuses to the Illinois Department of Labor they don’t see much benefit from it. The agency wouldn’t turnover wage claims for the past five years. But it released a sample of 51 claims filed between 2010 and 2013. Half of those complaints against temporary staffing agencies were dismissed after the labor department lost contact with the workers, according to records.

Advocates said that’s not surprising, given that many low-wage workers tend to move frequently.

The enforcement agency said these records only reflect a snapshot of the claims filed under the Day and Temporary Labor Service Act.

Of the $25,291 in claims filed with the state labor department, only $7,872.47 in back wages was recovered between 2010 and 2013, according to records. The processing time was long—on average it took about six months to process the wage claim.

For many of these low-wage workers, it’s easier to find a new job than wait to recover owed wages, said a Chicago temporary worker who didn’t want to be named for fear of retaliation.

“My neighbor helped me find a job at the temp agency where she worked,” the 63-year-old worker said. “But when she found out they weren’t paying her all the hours she was working, she looked for another job. She never reported it. She lost that money.”

That’s a risk many undocumented workers take if they want to work, she said.

Unlike undocumented workers, Roberto Gutierrez refused to walk away from a temp job without his pay. Gutierrez, who got his GED in 2008, worked in a warehouse loading containers. When he received his first check from Eclipse staffing in 2011, he noticed that the agency paid him $57 for 12 hours of work, less than minimum wage. He decided to confront his employer. He didn’t have a pay stub because the agency paid him using a “payroll card.”

The state allows staffing agencies to pay workers using “payroll cards” but only under strict guidelines. Aside from making sure employees agree to this form of payment, companies are required to provide an itemized statement of hours worked, rate of pay and deductions for each pay period.

Eclipse staffing didn’t ask Gutierrez if he wanted to be paid with the card and didn’t provide documentation of the hours he worked, according to a class-action lawsuit filed against the agency. Warehouse Workers for Justice, an advocacy organization, helped Gutierrez and other workers file the lawsuit. Unlike some of his co-workers, he didn’t stay quiet.

“I was legitimately pissed,” the 23 year old said. “I get pretty sick of hearing, that employers do whatever they want, and we [Mexicans] will sit back and take it. That didn’t sit well with me.”

Gutierrez contacted the Warehouse Workers for Justice to get help then. He later joined a group of another six workers in a class action lawsuit against Eclipse and Mid-West Temp group for failing to pay them minimum wage and failing to pay for all the hours worked, according to the lawsuit.

Eclipse did not respond to requests for an interview.

A systemwide problem
This growing sector is riddled with wage violations, said Leone Bicchieri, executive director of the Chicago Workers’ Collaborative.

“There are no good or bad agencies. It is a systemwide problem,” said Bicchieri. “We want to get this system regulated so that workers are not afraid to speak out.”

The staffing agencies are trying to get contracts with warehouses and factories, and the agency with the lowest bid gets the contract. That’s the real problem, Bell said.

“There needs to be a floor established on what temp agencies charge host employers for labor, which takes into account the costs of employee wages, unemployment comp, workers comp, government taxes, safety training and compliance with all regulations,” Bell said. “Retailers and other beneficiaries of temp staffing labor should be held accountable for insuring compliance with this ‘pricing floor’.”

Without it, vulnerable workers will continue to tolerate wage abuses in order to keep working, he said.

“The problem is that no one wants to say anything because they want to keep their job,” said Gaspar, who quit Staffing Network in December 2012 and is still looking for a job. “We all need to work. But it is degrading to be treated this way.”

Watch coverage of the investigation by The Chicago Reporter's partner, NBC 5.



newsletter

Get Involved

We invite readers to get more involved with the Chicago Reporter. Here's how: