Decatur resident Manley Mallard said Google has an opportunity to change course by supporting the POWER Act, proposed legislation that would require data centers to bring new clean energy resources to the grid, and investing in solar and battery storage to power its facilities. (Photo by Jack Austin) 

Decatur residents are pushing back against a proposed 452-megawatt natural gas plant – large enough to supply electricity to 300,000 to 400,000 homes – that would supply power to a Google data center, warning that the project could worsen air pollution and threaten the community’s drinking water. 

On Thursday, Nov. 12, members of the Illinois Clean Jobs Coalition and Decatur residents gathered outside Google’s Chicago headquarters in Fulton Market to urge the tech giant to abandon its agreement with Broadwing Energy and invest instead in renewable energy.

Google has labeled the plant as low-carbon, with the goal of removing up to 90 percent of CO2 through carbon capture and sequestration. Still, significant air pollution is expected to leak into Decatur, which has already been dubbed an environmental justice community due to preexisting industrial pollution and socioeconomic factors. 

What’s at stake in Decatur

Environmental advocates are raising alarms that a leak in the underground carbon storage system could threaten Lake Decatur, which provides drinking water to approximately 70,000 people.

This was not the first controversy surrounding carbon storage in Decatur. ADM detected a carbon dioxide leak at its facility in March 2024 but did not notify the EPA until July or inform Decatur officials before the city approved an easement expanding its storage operations beneath Lake Decatur in May.

The company subsequently paused injections after EPA testing found evidence of fluid movement between underground formations. ADM attributed the leak to corrosion in a monitoring well, though the company said there was no impact on surface or groundwater sources. The incident raises concerns about the safety of plans to store additional carbon dioxide underground as part of the proposed Broadwing project.

Growing opposition from residents

Dawn Dannenbring, a member of the community justice organization Illinois People’s Action, said the proposed plant contradicts Google’s promise to run on clean energy by 2030. Dannenbring called on Google to “break its deal with dirty gas,” support the POWER Act — proposed Illinois legislation that would require large data centers to address their energy and water impacts, fund community benefits and increase environmental oversight — and visit Decatur to hear from residents, where opposition to the project is growing.

“We’re opposed because it will dump thousands of metric tons of pollution into the environment: nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, particulate matter, volatile organic compounds, hazardous air pollutants, all of those things in the air,” Dannenbring said.

Dawn Dannenbring, a member of community justice organization Illinois People’s Action and the emcee for the press conference, called for Google to consult with the Decatur community and to invest in renewable energy to power their data centers. (Photo by Jack Austin) 

She described Decatur as one of the “worst in the state” for environmental justice issues, pointing to its industrial history and elevated health problems.

Evelyn Rosenberger, a retired teacher and a Decatur resident for 64 years, said that she and her neighbors will face the consequences if underground carbon leaks into the drinking water. Rosenberger said that residents are frustrated that large corporations can dictate what happens in the community without considering the people that live there. 

“People in the town are furious. They are afraid of what’s going to happen to our community, our livelihoods,” Rosenberger said. “It’s all about the money,” she said. “They need to know it’s not going to be fine in Decatur. This is our community; it’s not theirs.”

Retired teacher and Decatur resident for 64 years Evelyn Rosenberger said that she is concerned carbon stored underground might leak into Lake Decatur, a major source of drinking water. She spoke at the event, and told TCR people in town “are furious” that large corporations are trying to impose themselves without community input. “This is our community,” she said. (Photo by Jack Austin) 

An opportunity to change course 

Decatur resident Manley Mallard said Google has an opportunity to change course by supporting the POWER Act, proposed legislation that would require data centers to bring new clean energy resources to the grid, and investing in solar and battery storage to power its facilities.

“It can live its self-proclaimed values,” Mallard said. “It can choose clean air and a more resilient climate. To me, the choice is clear: no Broadwing gas plant.”

Kavi Chintam, a campaign manager at energy nonprofit Vote Solar, said that Google, like any big corporation, has a mandate to serve the community. While Google has relatively aggressive sustainability goals compared to other corporations, Chintam said the Broadwing plant stands as a glaring contradiction in policy and action – solar panels on buildings does not make up for bankrolling dirty gas in an Illinois community. 

In front of Google’s Chicago headquarters, Chintam said that “how we require data centers to be powered today will determine this state’s climate legacy.” Like others at the press conference, Chintam pushed for adoption of solar energy. 

Decatur residents hold signs outside Google Headquarters saying “Don’t Mess With Illinois, Google”, “Public Business Belongs in Public View”, and “No Gas” at a press conference in opposition to a Google-backed gas plant. (Photo by Jack Austin) 

Balancing energy needs with commitments to the environment

One reason data center developers have turned to natural gas is that it provides firm, dispatchable electricity that can be supplied around the clock to meet consistent power demands. Chintam acknowledged that the intermittency of utility-scale solar presents a challenge, but she said advances in battery storage, demand response and virtual power plants can help address fluctuations in renewable energy generation and make it possible to meet data center electricity needs with clean energy.

Nuclear power also provides consistent, low-carbon electricity and is included in Illinois’ statutory definition of clean energy under the Climate and Equitable Jobs Act. However, the Illinois Clean Jobs Coalition does not consider nuclear a clean energy source. New nuclear power plants also typically take considerably longer to develop and build than solar or natural gas facilities.

One protester holds a sign showing a puppet being controlled by Broadwing Energy and Google. Another says “Make room at the table… We’ll bring our own chairs.” Speakers on Thursday called for greater community involvement and expressed opposition for the Broadwing gas plant. (Photo by Jack Austin) 

Chintam, who holds a PhD in chemical engineering from Northwestern University and researched carbon capture, said the carbon capture technology would not eliminate the Broadwing plant’s environmental impacts. While the facility is designed to capture approximately 90 percent of its carbon dioxide emissions, that figure does not represent a 90 percent reduction in overall pollution.

The plant would still release carbon dioxide and other air pollutants, including nitrogen oxides, while methane leaks during natural gas production and transportation could add to its overall climate impact. Chintam also noted that carbon capture requires extensive pipeline construction and underground drilling, which can disrupt surrounding ecosystems and communities.

Despite facing a powerful corporate adversary, Rosenberger said Decatur residents were committed to seeing the fight through and stopping the proposed gas plant.

“The Illinois People’s Action is just a small group of people,” Rosenberger said. “We’re a David fighting a Goliath, and we just have to keep at it until we win the battle, and we’re going to keep after it.